Saturday, April 20, 2013

TFWs, RBC, and Entitlements Oh My!






Definition of ENTITLEMENT
1a : the state or condition of being entitled : right
  b : a right to benefits specified especially by law or contract
2: a government program providing benefits to members of a specified group;
    also: funds supporting or distributed by such a program
3: belief that one is deserving of or entitled to certain privileges




We keep hearing the word entitlement like it is a dirty thing. Politicians and their supporters (usually of a certain party but sometimes not) bandy this word around and usually in a negative way. They use it for things like social assistance and Employment Insurance and they tend to portray the recipients as less than well… human in many cases.

But recently I came across a new use of entitlement, one that I haven’t seen before…


But U.S. business consultant Steve Siebold says this anger is misdirected and that Canadians have no right to complain. Outsourcing is a reality, and it is not the bank’s responsibility to provide Canadian jobs, he said.
“It’s time to drop the entitlement mentality that just because you live in the neighbourhood [that] means a company should hire you. At the end of the day, you are responsible for what happens to you,” he said.
“To expect that the government, a local bank or anyone else is going to come riding in on the white horse to save you is ridiculous.”



Did you catch it in there? “Entitlement mentality”?

This comment was lifted from an op-ed piece in the Huffington Post on the use of Temporary Foreign Workers (TFWs) by the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC). You may have heard about this, it has been all over the news.

Our friend Steve Siebold says that it is A OK for a profitable business like the RBC to bring in temporary workers to replace their current employees and I’ll wager he thinks that it is peachy keen that the RBC have those soon to be former employees training the TFWs that are going to replace them. He goes on to accuse people who think this is wrong of having that entitlement mentality and then tosses in some blather about governments and banks on white horses riding in to save you… Well, let’s put it this way, I’ve never seen a banker or a government riding a horse, but I have seen them shovel a fair share of horse excrement in our direction. Maybe they named a pile of it “Steve”?

I think Steve is looking at this bass ackward. You see these other things that get called entitlements are really parts of our social safety net, our social contract. People saw what happened in bad times and how people were left destitute and suffering and society decided that this had to change. If you lose your job and you have been paying into the Employment Insurance pool you should be able to collect payments. If you are unable to find work and EI runs out, we have social assistance to tide you over until you do find work. We don’t want people starving in the streets, begging for pennies from those who are fortunate enough to still have their jobs. We’ve seen that before, we don’t want to see it again.

But there is another social contract that Steve ignores. Remember when you were younger and people told you to get an education so that you can get a good job? If you have kids you’ve probably told them that too.

These reason that I lump this into the social contract is that it wasn’t just parents saying this to their own kids, but it was everyone. It was the teachers, the community leaders, everyone on up to the government.

But we’re not talking about people trying to get jobs at the bank. We are talking about people who have jobs at the bank.

The entitlement mindset doesn’t belong to the workers, it belongs to Steve Siebold and the RBC. They believe that as an employer they are entitled to toss perfectly good workers into the street because they can get some people from India or wherever to do the work for cheap. So cheap in fact that they can afford to pay a middleman or an agency a fee to bring these TFWs into Canada for them.  

Do you see the government running to the stables to get on their white horses? No, they’re running there to cover their asses, or burros, or donkeys, or whatever it is that Cabinet Ministers ride now days.

Speaking of horse poop, I see Mike Duffy managed to make the news again, and the Harper Party still doesn’t like the electoral boundaries in Saskatchewan, and they officially announced that they put the Royal back into the Military (again), and how about those pesky backbenchers…

I’ve read lately that the Harper Party’s issue with the TFWs is not that it happened, but that we found out.

That wouldn’t surprise me, but that’s just my opinion… I’m still entitled to have one.

Cheers! BC

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

April Fools and Patrick Brazeau


When I was in kiddie garden many years ago our teacher asked us what we were planning for April Fools Day. We took turns telling what we were going to say or do but one classmate had a little extra time with the teacher who pains to explain the difference between a joke and a lie.

I guess Senator in legal trouble Patrick Brazeau needs to have someone explain this to him as well.

Yesterday Patrick tweeted that he was "stepping down" and the announcement would be at 10 am today. He later tweeted April Fools.

I bet he about peed himself laughing at everyone scrambling to find out if this was true, was he resigning his Senate Seat?

Pat doesn't seem to realise that to many Canadians he IS the joke. He is the rather unfunny joke that Stephen Harper foisted on us. The Senator who rarely shows up. The Senator who claimed he resided at his daddy's house so he could collect the housing allowance even though he lived across the river from Ottawa. The Senator who thinks it's funny to be charged with Domestic Assault and Sexual Assault. The Senator who probably thinks it's a joke that he has been suspended from the Senate and still gets paid for being a disgrace to the Upper House.

Yeah, we're all laughing about that too. I hope my sarcasm isn’t being wasted there.

You know what would be really funny Pat? It would be hilarious if Governor General David Johnston called you up today and accepted your resignation.

Laters! BC

Friday, March 29, 2013

Immunization: The Bear Gets His Shots In



I had a bit show up in my news feed again about the anti-vaccination folks, the vaxxers.

I gather that most of these people are younger than me, and I was fortunate, polio had been all but eradicated around the time I was born. But just barely.

My sister was one of the early recipients of the first polio vaccines, she is just a few years older than I am. People today don't know the terror of a disease that could strike your child and cripple or kill him. The March of Dimes was founded to help families affected by polio and to try and prevent the disease. You may have heard of them. Franklin Roosevelt was stricken with polio and it left him unable to walk, Forrest Gump was likely a polio survivor too.

As I said, I was lucky.

Today many childhood diseases have been largely eradicated because of advances in medicine, mainly vaccinations.

When I was a kid, almost everyone had a scar on their shoulder from getting a vaccine. I didn't have one, I was a baby when I got my shot and it healed very nicely. I can remember like lining up for our shots in school, everyone took home a letter that we were to have our shots and everyone brought back the signed slip... And everyone got their shots.

Back then rubella, the German measles was the big one. They weren't so worried about us, but if you came in contact with a pregnant woman her unborn child was at risk of birth defects.

We suffered through the then normal childhood diseases, chicken pox, measles, mumps, and so on. Some people even went so far as to host parties when their kids were sick so all the neighbourhood kids would get it too... And parents sent their kids willingly, a way to control when your child got sick and to make sure they did get the childhood diseases while still kids.  These things can be more dangerous if you contract them as an adult.

And yes, big pharma makes money from vaccines, they also make money from Aspirin and Tylenol too.

The thing that they seem to forget is that these childhood diseases aren't always just icky-sicky for a week things. The mumps can cause sterility, other diseases can cause deafness or blindness or death. In the developing world these diseases are a huge problem with mortality rates of over 20%, and these are preventable deaths from preventable diseases.

As I write this there is an outbreak of measles in the UK that is nearing epidemic proportions. People there didn't bother to vaccinate their children apparently thinking there was no need. Now they are scrambling to get the shots before their kids get sick.

When I was little a measles outbreak would affect one grade in the school, chances are that the older kids had their bout with it when they were in that grade as well. Imagine a whole school where few if any of the kids have been exposed to the measles, we're not looking at a handful of kids anymore, but of potentially hundreds sick at the same time.

I guess it depends on your priorities.

But if your child comes down with one of the childhood diseases and you have to wait because a few hundred other kids are in line at the Emerge or the doctor's office, don't complain to me. You have the opportunity to prevent these diseases from affecting your child, and if you don't, it is your fault.

If you want to get your information from the Internet, be my guest, but talk to your health care provider first. After all, they are in the business of keeping you healthy, aren't they?

Thankfully the number of children here in Canada who suffer complications from these diseases is very small. Part of this is that vaccinations have made these diseases fairly rare. Keep in mind that it's a numbers game, if there are 1,000 cases across Canada, chances are you won't know the few that develop complications. If there is an outbreak in your community affecting 1,000 you very well could know some of the families that end up dealing with the complications.

Many people today have never heard someone suffer from whooping cough and their only experience with polio is pictures or film clips from the 1950s and earlier. Vaccinations have removed these diseases from our part of the world and vaccinations keep them at bay. Wouldn't it be nice to put all preventable diseases on the shelf with them so the worst thing most parents would have to deal with is a skinned knee?

Cheers! BC

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Harper wades in on the Senate’s Residency question… Did he get it wrong?




I read on the Global Toronto New site that Stephen Harper has put to rest the allegations that some Senators may not be eligible to sit in the Senate…


Questions have been raised as to whether they spend sufficient time in their home provinces or territory to meet the constitutional residency requirement.

"All senators conform to the residency requirements," Harper told the House of Commons.

"That is the basis on which they are appointed to the Senate and those requirements have been clear for 150 years."




The story goes on to say


A government official said Harper interprets the residency requirement to mean that senators must "own residences and maintain deep ties" to their home province.


There is just one problem.  He’s got it wrong.

There is nothing in the Constitution about “deep ties” and the part about “own residences” is only part of the story.  To refresh your memory I’ll provide you with a snippet from the British North America Act of 1867 (BNA).


23   The Qualifications of a Senator shall he as follows:

…

(5)He shall be resident in the Province for which he is appointed:

(6)In the Case of Quebec he shall have his Real Property Qualification in the Electoral Division for which he is appointed, or shall be resident in that Division.



I’ve included both section 5 and 6 for a reason.  In Quebec, 65 of the Senators are named from Electoral Divisions.  In Quebec, the Senator must wither be resident in that Electoral Division or can hold property in that Division.  This shows that simply owning property in a Jurisdiction does not automatically make you resident in that Jurisdiction.

Section 5 would also cover Senators from Quebec the same as any other Province.  Note the wording “shall be resident in”, doesn’t that strike you as an odd way of wording the Qualification?

These parts of the BNA still stand as written all those years ago.

I was puzzled by the words “be resident in”.  It is a simple Qualification rule.  You must live in the Province you represent, so why the strange wording.

This phrase, while unusual in Canada is still used in the UK today.  Citizens of the Commonwealth are permitted to vote in the elections there if they are resident in the UK.  They have lived there long enough to be considered  resident.  Under their tax laws, if you are a citizen of the UK but do not spend enough time there (183 days in a year) you are not considered resident in the UK and the way you are taxed may change.

The issue is not about “residency” per se, but are the Senators “resident in” their given Provinces.  That is the $64 question.  If you live in Ontario, have and Ontario Driver’s Licence and OHIP card, if you pay your taxes to Ontario, can you sit as a Senator from some other Province?  From what I’ve read, there are a few Senators “from” some Provinces who appear to actually be “resident in” other Provinces.

This is what the Senate needs to clear up.

I was born in Ontario and have lived in Ontario my whole life.  If I were to move to another Province, set up housekeeping there and get my Health Card and Driver’s Licence there, would I still be eligible to sit as a Senator from Ontario?  Stephen Harper says yes, as long as I hold property in Ontario and “maintain ties” with Ontario which could mean I visit my family for Christmas I guess or that I stay in touch and occasionally visit friends there.

But my actions state otherwise.  By taking out a Health Card and Driver’s Licence I signal my intention to reside in my new Province, to be resident in that new Province.  If I don’t intend on becoming a resident in that new Province, there are steps I can take with the Province of Ontario to remain an Ontarian.

Alas, I’m wrong.

CBC news is reporting that Mike Duffy is eligible to sit in the Senate.  The legal advice that the Senate sought has come through and by merely signing a document you can be the Senator for “your” Province.


Please, go read the story, and while you are there, read the Declaration that the “Senator” will have to sign.  I’ve read it twice.

If you can find where in the Declaration it says that the Senator “is resident in” or any other words that state residency please point it out to me.

It ain’t there kids.

The fix is in… maybe I should move to Beartopia, it’s nice there this time of year, and there is no Harper Party there either.

BC