Showing posts with label elections canada. Show all posts
Showing posts with label elections canada. Show all posts

Saturday, April 12, 2014

Pierre Poilievre and the Not So Fair Elections Act



Here is just a taste of irony to start things off.

Following the 2011 General Election there were charges of voter fraud in the riding of Etobicoke Centre.  What happened was that there were a number of votes challenged because some people had voted outside of their own polling station even though their name was stroked off in their home polling station meaning they may have voted twice. Others had been allowed to vote without showing their voters card or any other ID, and some had been “vouched votes” but the paperwork for these votes were incomplete or in some cases nonexistent.

The Harper Party took the matter to the Supreme Court of Canada, but they weren’t the ones trying to get these votes removed.  They were defending these votes.

They argued successfully at the SCC that the removal of these votes which would have turned the seat over to Liberal Borys Wrzesnewskyj that would be an affront to the voters that had supported their winner Ted Opitz.

Fast forward to today and Bill C-23, the Fair Elections Act. 

Suddenly the Harper Party has decided that under no circumstances should these “vouched votes” be accepted.  If you do not have proper ID, you do not vote. 

I’m not sure if this is a flip-flop or just hypocrisy.

Pierre (Skippy) Poilievre says his bill is terrific, that it isn’t based on expert opinions but on common sense.  That’s how he can so easily brush aside any criticism from knowledgeable people like Sheila Fraser, Marc Mayrand, and so forth.  If you’re not one these ivory tower elites and question this bill you are some lefty nut job and not worthy of the time to refute your case.

Well let’s try some common sense.

If voter fraud caused by vouching was a real issue wouldn’t there have been complaints from across the country about this?  Aside from the Etobicoke Centre challenge, I really haven’t heard any complaints about it.

No, but I have heard plenty of complaints from across the country about RoboCalls.  Why aren’t they controlled or banned in this bill? Wouldn’t that make sense?

Skippy’s bill wants to let the winners of the elections pick the officials for the next election.  I sooo certain they would only pick honourable people and that there would be no favouritism shown at all.  That would be like the Chicago Black Hawks getting to pick the refs for the next season because they won the Stanley Cup.  How sensible does that sound?  Think Chicago would make the finals again the next year?

Bill C-23 looks to constrain the powers of the Chief Electoral Officer and Elections Canada.  To hear the Harper Party talk, there is an obvious bias against the Harper Party by these officials.

To tell the truth, the only cases of impropriety that I’ve heard about are with Harper Party candidates.  What does common sense say to that?

The Harper Party says elections at the local level are run by amateurs and mistakes will occur, Elections Canada is chasing only their party for these minor offences.  Well, maybe, but it’s more likely that these minor offences were dealt with by the other offenders when they arose.  Common senses says that mistakes would likely happen about the same amount of time for all the parties, but only one party makes it a habit of not correcting these errors promptly.  Or maybe there is only one party that broke the rules?

Skippy complains that Marc Mayrand only wants more power and more money to run Elections Canada.  Well it does take years to get anything done through Elections Canada when questions of impropriety arise.  Shouldn’t EC be able to get a warrant to compel witnesses to speak?  Shouldn’t EC have the people available to investigate allegations and inform the public of these charges and whether they find enough merit in these cases to proceed with a full investigation?

Skippy, if you have issues with EC having the power to actually investigate and take action then maybe YOU have something to hide?

No, Common Sense wants elections determined on who present the best case on why Me and My Party have the best options for Canada, not who can raise the most money.

Common Sense wants a neutral party to oversee elections and to challenge and punish rule breakers.

Common Sense wants the same type of rules that govern income tax to cover elections.  If you show campaign expenses, those expenses need to be accompanied by receipts to show how that money was spent.  We refund a portion of those expenses, we want accountability.

And Common Sense wants anyone who is a Canadian Citizen and who is of legal age to vote to be able to vote. 

We have come a long way from when an MP was selected by a show of hands by men who held property.  It took a long time before we allowed women to vote and an even longer time before we allowed the First Nations to vote.  These were steps in the right direction.

When I first voted, I simply walked into the polling station, told them who I was and they handed me a ballot.  We didn’t have widespread voter fraud then, we don’t have it now.  But now I need to provide ID or at least have someone who has valid ID vouch for me.  The same routine you’d probably have to do if you take your 18 year old to vote if they don’t have a drivers licence.

For over 100 years we could vote with no ID required.  If you are truly worried about voter fraud Skippy, why not put in a rule where I need to stick my finger in the inkwell when my ballot goes into the box?  I don’t have an issue with this, it would be a source of pride to show that I have voted.

But I get to choose the finger.

Cheers! BC

In the mean time, since this flawed bill is going to be rushed through the pipes faster than any bill in the history of Canada, if you are concerned that you don’t have enough ID to vote, march your tuchas down to the nearest Provincial (or Territorial) Government office and get your Provincial/Territorial ID.  In Ontario it will cost you $35.00 and is good for 5 years, but maybe paying $35.00 will give you the initiative to get your butt out to vote?

Laters, BC

Friday, June 14, 2013

Stephen Harper Needs Your Money!



Did you get your call yet?

I haven’t, but a friend of mine did.  Stephen Harper needs money to defend you against heroin addicts using safe injection sites and other assorted scary things…

The news of this made for some interesting conversation, why would Stephen Harper need money now?  The next election is already slated for 2015, is there going to be a snap election to surprise everyone?  Maybe the Harper Party needs to start working on more non election Attack Ads, this wouldn’t surprise me since the last one went over so well.

That was sarcasm by the way.  The last ad generated lots of money, for the Liberal Party of Canada.

I’m more of the opinion that Stephen Harper needs your money because he has spent a pile of bucks on lawyers, and they don’t come cheap.

Do you remember the Etobicoke election?  The Liberal candidate, Borys Wrzesnewskyj challenged the results because of “irregularities” in the vote.  The Harper Party man, Ted Opitz countered the argument and the whole thing went to court.  Borys, using his own money won the first round and the results were overturned leaving Ted to decide if the ruling would be challenged at the Supreme Court of Canada.  At the last minute Ted’s team took the case to the high court.  Ted had to get clearance from the Harper Party I guess, since they were bankrolling his legal team.  I wonder how much it costs to contest a case at the Supreme Court.  I’ll wager it isn’t cheap.  Ted won, by the way and has gone on to represent Canada as a voting observer overseas.  The irony is… well words fail me.

How about the Robocalls challenge in 6 contested ridings?  The Council of Canadians backed the 8 people who were arguing that the elections in their ridings were affected by fraudulent Robocalls and the 6 Harper Party People who had won in those seats took to their lawyers to fight this.

Although the 6 MPs retained their seats, the judge found that the “trench warfare” and other means of delaying and trying to derail the case meant that the MPs would not be reimbursed for their expenses.  The Harper Party will remain on the hook for the bulk of the legal costs.  The judge even noted that the Harper Party money was underwritten by the taxpayers of Canada in his ruling.

Add to this the Peter Penashue election expenses case where the Harper Party repaid the money in question for Penashue so he could run in the by election in Labrador as well as his legal costs I’m sure.

Currently there are two Harper Party MPs in trouble with Elections Canada and they are starting litigation to retain their seats and there appears to be at least one more of these cases on the horizon.

More time in court, more Harper Party money for the lawyers.  And these are just the highlights, there’s probably a lot more that never made the press.

So why should I care that the Harper Party is spending tons of cash in the court room anyway?  For the simple reason that I am paying for it.  So are you.

I haven’t donated to the Harper Party, I’ve never donated to any party.  Most people haven’t.

But… the people who do donate get a percentage of their donation back at tax time.

You and I are subsidising the Harper Party.

If someone gives the Harper Party, or any other party $200.00, they get back $150.00 from the government.  We make up the difference.  When you get your call they’ll even brag about this to you.

All these court cases, all the attack ads, the computer database that the Harper Party maintains with information on virtually every Canadian alive is paid for, in part, by You and Me.  I don’t know if the $90,000.00 that Nigel Wright gave to Mike Duffy came out of the Harper Party Fund, but I’ll bet the cost of the lawyer brought in by Nigel was.

For the record, it wouldn’t bother me all that much if they located a safe injection site in my area.  The police would keep an eye on it and the people using the service would be encouraged to not loiter in the area.  It would probably be far safer than having a crack just down the street from me.

And there really was a crack house just down the street from me.

Cheers, BC

Friday, November 23, 2012

Some Musings on the Canada Elections Act



Imagine if you will a competition.  Before it starts, the referee explains the rules and sets the guide lines and then the competition begins.

The referee watches the competition but seems oblivious to what is going on.  He call no fouls, even when onlookers cry out about illegal moves.  He might occasionally give warnings about inappropriate actions during the competition, but those warnings can be denied and ignored.

At the end of the competition the referee declares the winner.

Sounds a bit like pro wrestling, doesn’t it?

Actually it sounds a lot like our election system in Canada.

Elections Canada seems to have very little power when it comes to the actual election campaigns.  They get to shout “Go!” at the beginning and count the votes at the end to declare the victor.

One, two, three.

More recently we had another vote.  It was in the House of Commons to see what would happen to Bill C-424, a Bill to amend the Elections Act of Canada.

A fellow in Liberal red trunks named Dominic LeBlanc, hailing from Beauséjour (New Brunswick) proposed this bill, which would raise the fines for infractions under the Act from $2000 and $5000 to $20,000 and $50,000 for breaking the rules.  For doing things like preventing people from voting, or causing a disturbance at a polling station to prevent people from voting, or intentionally overspending their limit during an election… It’s all in sections 481 through 499 of the Canada Election Act.

And it would allow the Chief Electoral Officer to contest the result of an election where questionable things happened.

Imagine that, people call Elections Canada about unscrupulous matters occurring in an election and Elections Canada can’t go to the court and say “Here’s what happened, review the results.”  Today, only a voter in that particular riding or a candidate for that riding can go to the courts if they feel that an election was unfairly won.

Some referee eh?  Here’s your striped shirt, but no whistle, not even a flag to throw.

Well on November 21st there was a vote to see if Bill C-424 would go to Committee and it was clearly a partisan vote.  The Opposition side all voted in favour of the Bill and the Harper Party voted against it. 

Goodbye to Bill C-424.

The system is broken.  We saw that when Borys Wrzesnewskyj contested the Etobicoke election results and initially won.  Borys spent a large amount of money in his efforts to show that the Etobicoke election was flawed and that a new election should be held.  Far more money than you or I would be able to spend if we believed the results of an election should be overturned.

The Chief Electoral Officer should be able to go to the courts and have the results reviewed if there is evidence of wrongdoing.  It shouldn’t be up to you or me to fight in court against a political party that is willing to spend the case into the Supreme Court of Canada like we saw in Borys’ case.

In the USA there were reports that the group anonymous may have interfered with the Republican Party’s get out the vote computer system.  There were concerns that they may have broken several federal election laws (in the US) not for interfering with the vote, or the voting machines, but for interfering with a political party’s computers.

Here we have Pierre Poutine and a number of other infractions under the Canada Election Act and nobody on the Harper Party side of the House seems to give a rat’s patoot about it.

We obviously need some reforms and Bill C-424 was a start, and yet Harper’s crew won’t have any of it. 

Isn’t funny how the self professed Law and Order party of Lord Stephen seems to have no concerns about electoral fraud and robocalls and overspending by candidates or candidates receiving illegal corporate donations, et cetera, et cetera…

If you smell what this cat…. Is cooking.

Apologies for the wrestling references, it’s a weakness ;o)
Cheers, BC

Monday, October 29, 2012

Supreme Court of Canada VS Democracy



Well the Supreme Court of Canada heard the arguments and had their deliberations and reached a verdict…

And Ted Opitz retains his seat.

I think this is a bad ruling.  I am not alone.

This is not a partisan issue, but it could be in the future. 

It is a responsibility issue. 

Voting is not democracy, it is only a part of it.  But it is the only part that many people take part in.  The fact that ballots were cast without proper records kept is troubling.

Most of us take the Voter Card with us when we go to vote simply because it says to on the card.  Some of us forget our cards, some of us don’t have a card because we moved recently and didn’t have an opportunity to get the new card before the election and that is why there are provisions in place to handle these instances.

If I were to show up at the polls without my card and without enough documentation to show who I am, I can still vote if someone verifies who I am. 

“I know Bear Cat, he lives down the street from me. Here’s my documentation to show who I am, I’ll sign for him.”

This document is my proof.  It is a government document and should be treated as such.  If the document is lost, or not filled out properly then should my vote count?

The Court says yes.  I say no.

Simply put, the number of ballots in the box should equal the number of people stroked off the list plus any documents for people who weren’t on the list but were eligible to vote at that poll.

And the documents must be complete.

It is not that hard, and yet with our Elections Canada staff and scrutineers from the parties there it still happened.

I’m not calling for anything as severe as some of the legislation in the US where you cannot vote unless you provide proper documentation.  These laws are so strict that voters can be denied simply because they do not drive.  Let’s face it, besides our driver’s licence most of us don’t have enough Government Issue documentation to prove who we are.

Our system is simple and it works if it is applied properly.  In this case there was a breakdown and Elections Canada cannot show that every ballot cast was proper.  This leaves an opening for abuse and hindsight being what it is, if there is an opportunity for abuse, abuse will occur.

If this had happened during a “normal” election where the plurality is usually in the hundreds if not thousands, this would not be such an issue… But it still would be an issue.

Boris Wrzesnewskyj’s challenge to the results of the past federal election in Etobicoke was because the number of disputed ballots was greater than the plurality, the number of votes that decided the election in that riding.  Ted Opitz countered that overturning the result would disenfranchise voters, telling them that their vote didn’t count.

We do not know who the disputed ballots were for.  We do not know if they were all for one candidate or another.  But we do not know that they weren’t either.  We don’t know if these people voted twice, or were entitled to vote at all.

The Supreme Court of Canada had an opportunity to tell Canadians that their vote is important, that the rules in place are good.  They chose not to.

Four votes to Three.  The right of a citizen to vote is more important than the determination of whether an individual is entitled to vote.

At the very root of this it is not a Wrzesnewskyj vs Opitz matter or even a Liberal vs Harper Party matter.  It is about our faith in the system and that Elections Canada must show that they are capable of handling a proper election.

It appears that Elections Canada may not be capable… But the Supreme Court of Canada saved their bacon.

Afterthought… In a post ruling photo-op with Ted Opitz, Stephen Harper said something about improving our election system.  Why does this scare me?

Happy Hallowe’en, BC