Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Of Senators and Constitutional Questions.



All the recent news regarding the Senate and the Senators was basically making me numb to the issue.  Seriously, it seems to be a part of a plan to make us all idiots.  After something happens, such as the Duffy Affair we get inundated with glop from the media and from the Parties to the point where it just doesn’t seem to matter anymore.

And then Peter Van Loan opened his mouth.

What Peter had to say was quoted in the National Post:


“Senator Patterson, Wallin and Duffy all own property in the provinces and territory they represent,” Peter Van Loan, the government’s House leader, told the Commons on Monday.

“They maintain deep, continuing ties to those regions. In fact, all three senators spend considerable time in their home provinces and territory.”



Well, that ground my gears.  Again we are seeing the Harper Party and their Law and Order™ agenda that applies to everyone except for the Harper Party itself.

When it comes to the Senate and more specifically the rules governing who can sit in it, the Constitution is quite specific.

 The Qualifications of a Senator shall be as follows:
1)    He shall be of the full age of Thirty Years;

2)    He shall be either a natural-born Subject of the Queen, or a Subject of the Queen naturalized by an Act of the Parliament of Great Britain, or of the Parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, or of the Legislature of One of the Provinces of Upper Canada, Lower Canada, Canada, Nova Scotia, or New Brunswick, before the Union, or of the Parliament of Canada after the Union;

3)    He shall be legally or equitably seised as of Freehold for his own Use and Benefit of Lands or Tenements held in Free and Common Socage, or seised or possessed for his own Use and Benefit of Lands or Tenements held in Franc-alleu or in Roture, within the Province for which he is appointed, of the Value of Four thousand Dollars, over and above all Rents, Dues, Debts, Charges, Mortgages, and Incumbrances due or payable out of or charged on or affecting the same;   

4)    His Real and Personal Property shall be together worth Four thousand Dollars over and above his Debts and Liabilities;

5)    He shall be resident in the Province for which he is appointed;

6)    In the Case of Quebec he shall have his Real Property Qualification in the Electoral Division for which he is appointed, or shall be resident in that Division. (13) 



Pretty straight forward aren’t they?

Well except for maybe #3 which is written in lawyer speak…

But the one I’m looking at is number 5. 

Pretty simple rule.  You shall be resident in the Province you are to represent.

I stressed the word shall for a very important reason.  In certain circles, words such as “can” or “may” or “should” are referred to as “weasel words” basically meaning that you can weasel your way around them.  “May” can also mean “may not”, it is not definite.  “Shall” on the other hand is a directive, there is no way to weasel around “shall”.

What Van Loan is saying is an affront to Canadians who believe in the rule of law, and the Constitution is the highest law in the land. 

In Stephen Harper’s efforts to twist the Senate into his distorted view of what it should be, he is opening up a Pandora’s Box that could put us into a “Constitutional Crisis”.  It’s not me saying this, those are retired Senator Lowell Murray’s words.

Part of the reason that this could cause such a crisis is found in Section 31 of the Constitution, part 5


 The Place of a Senator shall become vacant in any of the following Cases:

5)    If he ceases to be qualified in respect of Property or of Residence...

          Canada Justice Laws website



If any other Senators are found to have voted in Ontario, or carry an OHIP Card rather than their home Province’s Health Card, or fail to meet another of the criteria that the Senate Committee looking into the residency of Senators is using, they could be unceremoniously put out into the street.

What happens then?  Do we trust Stephen Harper to restock (or restack if you like) the Senate?  Does the Governor General use his power to select enough people to fill the Senate?  Maybe we should let the Privy Council do the selecting.

Or we could just leave the seats vacant and save a few bucks.

I honestly don’t know if the current Senate kerfuffle was created intentionally by the Harper People, I certainly hope not.  One thing I do know is that these Senators have been doing pretty good on the public dime, and if they weren’t eligible to sit in the Senate from Day One, someone needs to be reimbursing us.  If they were in the Senate and knew they shouldn’t be, then they should be paying… but if they were put in by someone who knew they shouldn’t be there, maybe He should be writing the cheque… 

A closing thought.  CBC contacted 104 Senators and asked them the same 5 questions that the Senate Committee has been asking asking.  Of the 96 that responded, 17 refused to provide information… 15 of those were Harper’s appointees...


Kinda makes you think, doesn’t it?


If you’d like to see the article, click here: CBC News
I’ve maintained for some time now that any member serving in the House of Commons or the Senate for that matter should be required to take an Oath and part of that Oath would be to protect the Constitution, similar to what our friends to the South have. 

Maybe we could at least have them read it?

Cheers, BC

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Where's Waldo Senate Style



If you've been following the news lately, you're probably aware of the current kerfuffle over the residency of our current crop of Senators.

What appears to have started as a targeted shot at one or two Senators is beginning to snowball into something much larger. Where do our Senators live when they aren't in the Senate?

Okay,  from what I gather this all started with someone wondering why some Senators were claiming living expenses for being in Ottawa even though they actually own homes in the area. One of these Senators is Mac Harb who sits as a Liberal in the Senate.

Senator Harb has owned a home in the Ottawa area going back to the 1970s, but he still claims Senate living expenses because his “home" is in Pembroke, Ontario. Pembroke is outside of the 100km limit to claim these living expenses.

If Senator Harb lived there before he got his appointment then he would be within the rules. Is this an abuse of the rules?  I'd say so, but my say so doesn't carry a lot of weight in these matters. This is just another one of those rules that the people in charge like to make to subsidize their own kind.

So another Senator, David Tkachuk (Conservative) has been given the job of determining the real residences of all the Senators.

Senator Tkachuk seems to be a reasonable man. He lives in Ottawa during the week and travels home on the weekends. We might be annoyed that he flies back and forth to Saskatchewan, but that's allowed, it is part of the rules... And at least we know where his residence is.

Now I don't know if Sen. Tkachuk had an agenda to target one or two Senators or if he wanted to make sure all the Senators were on the up and up, but he told the Senators that he needed proof of residency from all of them. He wanted copies of their Health Cards and Driver's Licenses, the same things you or I would show to prove where we live. Oh and proof of where they vote.

After Sen. Tkachuk made his request, odd things started to happen. A certain fellow from PEI suddenly needed his Health Card renewed and some people wondered why if a Senator lived in their town, they had never seen them. And then the News People woke up.

Our News Folks might be late to parties, but when they smell blood they dive right in.

Curiously Sen. Harb seems to have fallen off of the radar being replaced by much higher profile Senators...

Senator Duffy (Conservative) who suddenly needed his Health Card renewed found out that he can't renew it, he's been away so long he needs to apply for a new one. He doesn't qualify for the tax break for having a residence in PEI, and he apparently voted in the Ontario provincial election.

Senator Brazeau (Conservative) appears to own a home in the Ottawa area, but claims he lives with his Dad. Senator Brazeau also seems to have claimed residency on a Native Reserve at another time for tax breaks but no one there can recall him living there.

And now Senator Pamela Wallin (Conservative) is facing questions over her Saskatchewan residency. Although she owns property there, she has spent most of the last decade between New York City and Toronto.

Senator Tkachuk seems to have opened a can of worms and is now looking for outside help. What is a simple question to us may be more complicated issue in the Senate. Senator Tkachuk realizes that his way of maintaining a home may not work for others. It might be easier for some to live in Ottawa and visit "home" from time to time.

But the Constitution requires a Senator to reside in their home province and work in Ottawa.

So what does residency mean?

For most people this is easy. We live in our residences, we call it home. We go to work and sleep at home.  Some who live far from their jobs may spend the work week close to their job and travel home on weekends, much like Sen. Tkachuk does. Students may live at school or nearby, but come home for Christmas.

Actually students are a special group. When it comes to elections, students get to choose where they vote. They are allowed to vote either at home or where they live. But does that define residency?

That's the issue that Sen. Tkachuk is wrestling with.

The provinces also have rules governing residency.  Depending on where you live, the amount of time you need to spend there to be a resident varies. Most provinces will only allow you to be out of province for six months in a year.  Beyond that and your Health Card lapses. 

So what is a reasonable requirement?

The Senate is usually sits between 60 and 100 days in a year, but that doesn't take other Senate business into account. Senators have other duties besides sitting in the Senate Chambers, they also sit on Senate Committees as well as House of Commons Committees. Just as most MPs have duties outside of the House and Committee work Senators have other business to attend to as well.

To maintain our health insurance, we need to reside in our provinces for a certain number of days each year. The number of days varies by province,   122 (NL), 153 (ON), or 183 in the rest of Canada. Would it be reasonable to hold Senators to the same standard that applies to the rest of us?

The majority of us live with the 183 day rule, maybe they should too... Fair's fair isn't it?

Well maybe, but the Senate Schedule is a bit odd.  They usually run 20 to 24 weeks a year, but they run in blocks of 3 or 4 weeks with a week or two off in between and July and August set aside as summer vacation.

It is a bit of a mess, but I’m sure they will figure something out.  They always do… but I don’t know if anyone would accept Senator Duffy’s 60 days in PEI a year an acceptable standard.

I’m no longer a betting man, but I’d wager that if they do anything that it won’t adversely affect any sitting Senators...  If they set a number of days, it will likely be 122 or less…

Maybe they’ll surprise me. I’ll offer this idea to Senator Tkachuk for free… it shall be required that any person being considered for a seat in the Senate to provide proof of residency of 183 or more days per calendar year for the 3 years prior to being installed in the Senate.

It would have solved most of these problems before they happened, but actually knowing what you were doing would have solved most of these issues before they happened.  Like being aware that there is a residency requirement in the Constitution for Senators.  But when the guy making the picks says things like “I’m the Boss, I make the rules” I guess all bets are off.

Yes Steve, I’m looking at you.

Laters, BC

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Harper’s Senate Reforms? A Joke.



Want to read something funny?

Stephen Harper has Senator Bert Brown out trying to convince the provinces that their proposals for Senate Reform are Democratic.

Yep, the current system needs to be replaced with the vision that Steve and Bert put together one night at a road house eating steaks.

Now Steve’s proposal was that the Senate should be elected to 9 year terms.  But that a Senator could only sit for one term.  Elections=Democracy right?

They had elections in the USSR didn’t they?  Why weren’t they democratic?

Look, when we vote for our Mayors or Council Members or our MPs they tell us the wonderful things they will do for us.  Then the winners go and do whatever they do.  Now some of us pay attention and if the folks we elect don’t do what they said, or do a bad job, we don’t vote for them again.  That is electoral accountability.  If we elect a person to be Senator and they are an absolute disgrace, we can’t vote them out because they’re done anyways.  If we elect the best Senator to ever grace the Red Chamber and is an absolute joy to have, we can’t re-elect him. 

Where is the motivation to do your job well?  Where is the motivation to do anything more than show up often enough to collect your cheque?  There isn’t any.

Zero, zip, zilch, there’s no accountability whatsoever.

Did I mention that the elected Senators might not even get used?  The decision to recommend Senators will still rest with the PM, who only considers the elected Senators, no guarantee they’ll get the job.

Democratic Reform?  Whatever.

The second part is the doozie though.

Steve doesn’t want the now elected Senate to be able to stop a Bill put through the House of Commons.

So Steve asks Bert, how can we do this? 

Well Bert takes a long sip on his beverage and smiles.  “Remember Brian Mulroney?” he asks, “Remember how he got hosed on the Meech Lake Deal? Well we set the Senate up like the Constitution.  Darn near impossible to do anything with that.”

Basically what it boils down to is making it so difficult for the Senate to block a Bill, they might just as well pass it anyways.

Here we go.  The House passes a Bill, the vote is 154 to 153.  That is 50%+1, a simple majority.

Now the Senate looks at the Bill and they think, it’s not so good… we need to send it back.  So, within 12 sitting days or 30 calendar days the Senate has to vote to send it back… but there is no simple majority here, no sirree.

To send it back we need a majority of Senators from at least 7 provinces whose combined population represents 50% of the population of Canada.

Got that?

Scary bit is that every Senator from every province can vote to send it back, but if 13 Senators from Ontario and 13 from Quebec vote against it, well these two provinces hold more than 50% of the population and because the majority of these two provinces’ Senators went against… Well 26 Senators could oppose the will of the other 79.  Not very Democratic is it?

Obviously this is over the top, but the fact is it would be almost impossible to get a majority in 7 provinces and for those 7 to contain 50% of the population.  Ask Brian Mulroney.  He had 7 Premiers backing the Meech Lake Accord, those 7 contained the required 50%, and Meech died on a filibuster.

Look, the creaky old Senate has worked Okay for 145+ years.  The number of Bills that have been “killed” in the Senate or sent back to the House of Commons with amendments attached is surprisingly small.  Generally the Senate passes most things through.  The only time we notice the Senate is when they throw the brakes on a Bill or when a member or two behaves badly.

One of the good things of the appointed Senate is that they don’t have to hurry.  Senate committees can sit for years and make informed decisions, the House on the other hand only has a window of 4 years to ram through as much policy as they can.  In the rush, mistakes happen.  We see additions to Omnibus Bills to correct boners they pulled in previous Omnibus Bills.

Retired Senator Lowell Murray was incensed when he realized that a Harper Omnibus Bill changed the rules over the Finance Minister’s ability to borrow money in our name.  Senator Murray was upset because the Senate had missed it, and when he went to the Harper Party Caucus to get this “fixed” they blew him off.  Senator Murray was initially named to the Senate as a PC, he migrated to the Harper Party later on, and finished his career as an Independent Senator.

The Harper/Brown plan is a dog’s breakfast. With 8 or 9 year Senators, we will be paying more in Senate pensions than we pay for sitting Senators before the fourth Senatorial Election.  The cost of holding these elections will further inflate these costs.  And to top it off, the Senate’s hands will be collectively tied to the point where the Senate IS pointless.

And as I pointed out earlier, they won’t even be guaranteed a job.  They will only be considered, Steve can name someone else on a whim.

This is not Democratic Reform, it is a joke.

I don’t pretend that the Senate is perfect, it is far from it.  Churchill was wrestling with the Senate in the UK at the end of the Nineteenth Century, or rather the House of Lords.

Is there room for improvement?  Certainly, maybe we do need to rethink the Senate, but it is far too important a question to let the politicians play politics with it.

Harper’s Folly with his 8 year Senators is going to come home to roost in the coming years.  Each of these 8 year wonders will be eligible for over $30,000.00 in pensions and you know who will be paying for that. 

The bottom line, with all its warts, the Senate works Okay.  The fact that Harper has a vendetta against it speaks volumes in its favour.  IF we decide to look at revamping the Senate or possibly removing it, this needs to be considered by outsiders, people without a vested interest in the outcome of the study.

Do such people exist?  I imagine so, but whether or not they’d be willing to open this hornets’ nest is another story altogether.


Cheers, BC